Security · 7 min read

SIEM vs SOAR vs XDR: How They Differ and How They Work Together

SIEM vs SOAR vs XDR explained: what each does, comparison table, how a modern security operations stack combines them, and what a small or mid-size business actually needs.

A SIEM collects and stores logs from every system so you can search, correlate and prove compliance. A SOAR automates response through playbooks that act across your tools. An XDR detects and responds to threats using deep telemetry from a set of integrated security controls. SIEM is the memory, XDR is the detector, and SOAR is the hands. Modern platforms increasingly blend all three.

Comparison table

SIEMSOARXDR
Main jobLog collection, correlation, search, compliance reportingAutomating and orchestrating responseDetection and response across endpoint, network, email, identity, cloud
DataAny log source: firewalls, AAA, switches, servers, cloudAlerts from SIEM, XDR and ticketingRich telemetry from integrated sensors
OutputAlerts, dashboards, audit evidence, long-term retentionExecuted playbooks: block, disable, ticket, notifyCorrelated incidents with built-in response actions
Effort to runHigh: parsers, rules and tuningMedium: playbook designLower: detections come pre-built
Typical buyerRegulated organisations, SOCs, MSSPsMature SOCs with high alert volumeLean IT and security teams

How they work together

  1. XDR and network devices detect suspicious activity, such as a laptop beaconing to a known malicious domain.
  2. The SIEM adds context from AAA, VPN, DNS and firewall logs: who was logged in, from where, and what else that IP touched.
  3. A SOAR playbook isolates the laptop, disables the user's sessions, blocks the domain on the firewall and opens a ticket, all in seconds.
  4. The SIEM keeps the full record for the investigation and for auditors.

Which logs to send first

  • Identity and AAA: directory, identity provider, RADIUS and TACACS+ accounting. See the audit-trail tutorial.
  • Perimeter: firewall, VPN and gateway logs.
  • DNS queries.
  • Endpoint alerts from EDR or XDR.
  • Configuration changes on switches, routers and access points.

What a small or mid-size business needs

Start with EDR and an MDR service, plus central log storage, which can be an open-source SIEM such as Wazuh (see our Wazuh tutorial). Add XDR when tool sprawl creates alert overload. SOAR usually comes last, once you know which responses you repeat every week. For the detection side in detail, read EDR vs XDR vs MDR vs NDR.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between SIEM and XDR?

A SIEM collects logs from any source for search, correlation and compliance. XDR focuses on detecting and responding to threats with deep telemetry from integrated security tools. Many organisations use both.

Does XDR replace SIEM?

Not fully. XDR handles detection and response well, but a SIEM is still needed for long-term retention, compliance reporting and logs from sources XDR does not cover.

What is SOAR used for?

Automating repetitive response steps, such as enriching alerts, isolating hosts, blocking indicators and opening tickets, through playbooks that act across many tools.

Need help designing your network?

Navijin engineers provide free design consultations, bills of materials and quotations for business projects.