Security · 10 min read
EDR vs XDR vs MDR vs NDR: What Is the Difference and Which Do You Need?
EDR vs XDR vs MDR vs NDR explained: what each detects, the data it uses, how they relate to SIEM and SOAR, a comparison table and a practical buying order for small and mid-size businesses.
EDR (endpoint detection and response) watches laptops and servers for attacks and lets you isolate them. XDR (extended detection and response) correlates EDR data with network, email, identity and cloud signals into one investigation. NDR (network detection and response) finds attacks in network traffic, including on devices that cannot run an agent. MDR (managed detection and response) is a service: a provider's analysts run these tools for you around the clock. EDR and XDR are technologies. MDR is who operates them.
Comparison at a glance
| EDR | XDR | NDR | MDR | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Endpoint security tool | Cross-domain detection platform | Network traffic analysis tool | Managed security service |
| Data sources | Processes, files, registry, memory and connections on each endpoint | Endpoint + network + email + identity + cloud | Packets and flow records (NetFlow/IPFIX), DNS, TLS metadata | Whatever tools the provider runs: usually EDR or XDR |
| Sees devices without an agent | No | Partly, through network and identity data | Yes: cameras, IoT, OT, printers | Depends on tools |
| Typical response | Kill process, quarantine file, isolate host | Coordinated: isolate host, disable account, block sender or IP | Alert, block via firewall or NAC integration | Analysts investigate and respond for you, 24/7 |
| Needs in-house analysts | Yes | Fewer, thanks to correlation | Yes | No: that is the point |
| Best for | Every organisation, as the baseline | Lean teams drowning in alerts from separate tools | Networks full of unmanaged and IoT devices | Businesses without a 24/7 security team |
EDR: endpoint detection and response
Gartner analyst Anton Chuvakin named the category in 2013. Unlike traditional antivirus, which blocks known malicious files, EDR records endpoint behaviour continuously. It detects techniques such as credential dumping, suspicious PowerShell or ransomware encryption, and gives responders tools to isolate a host, kill processes and search all endpoints for the same indicators. Detections are usually mapped to the MITRE ATT&CK framework. Modern products bundle next-generation antivirus (NGAV) with EDR.
XDR: extended detection and response
Palo Alto Networks introduced the term in 2018. XDR takes EDR telemetry and adds network, email, identity and cloud data, then correlates them into one incident. For example, it links a phishing email, the user's login from a new country and a process on their laptop, instead of producing three unrelated alerts. Two flavours exist:
- Native (closed) XDR: one vendor's endpoint, firewall, email and identity products working together.
- Open (hybrid) XDR: integrates third-party tools through APIs and log feeds.
NDR: network detection and response
NDR analyses traffic, from mirrored switch ports (SPAN), network taps or flow records, to spot command-and-control beacons, lateral movement, data exfiltration and scanning. It matters because many devices, such as IP cameras, NVRs, building controllers and OT equipment, can never run an EDR agent. Good network design helps NDR: segmented VLANs make abnormal traffic stand out.
MDR: managed detection and response
MDR is a service. The provider deploys or takes over your EDR or XDR, monitors it 24/7, investigates alerts and either acts for you (isolating a laptop at 3 a.m.) or tells you exactly what to do. For most small and mid-size businesses, the real choice is not EDR versus XDR but whether anyone is watching the alerts. MDR answers that.
Related terms you will see
- ITDR (identity threat detection and response)
- Detects attacks on identity systems: Active Directory, identity providers, MFA fatigue and token theft. It closely complements AAA controls.
- SIEM (security information and event management)
- Collects and stores logs from everything for search, correlation, compliance and retention. See SIEM vs SOAR vs XDR.
- SOAR (security orchestration, automation and response)
- Runs automated response playbooks across tools.
- EPP (endpoint protection platform)
- Prevention-focused endpoint security (antivirus, NGAV, device control). EDR adds detection, investigation and response.
What to buy first: a practical order
- EDR on every laptop and server, with MFA and patching. This is the biggest single reduction in ransomware risk.
- Someone watching it 24/7: an MDR service if you have no security operations centre.
- Central logging of firewalls, VPN, AAA servers and switches for investigations. Our Wazuh SIEM tutorial shows an open-source start.
- XDR once you run several security tools and want one view and fewer, better alerts.
- NDR if you have many unmanaged, IoT, CCTV or OT devices.
How the network supports detection and response
Every response tool needs a network that can contain a threat. Navijin managed switches and NavGATE gateways provide VLAN segmentation and 802.1X with RADIUS, so a NAC or XDR workflow can move a suspect device into a quarantine VLAN. Talk to our engineers about designing a network that is ready for detection and response.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between EDR and XDR?
EDR monitors and responds on endpoints only. XDR combines endpoint data with network, email, identity and cloud data and correlates them into single incidents with coordinated response.
Is XDR better than EDR?
XDR builds on EDR rather than replacing it. Start with EDR everywhere. XDR adds value when you run several security tools and need fewer, correlated alerts.
What is the difference between XDR and MDR?
XDR is a technology platform. MDR is a managed service in which a provider's analysts monitor and respond using EDR or XDR on your behalf.
What is NDR used for?
Detecting threats in network traffic, including on devices that cannot run agents such as cameras, IoT and OT equipment.
Does antivirus count as EDR?
No. Traditional antivirus blocks known malware. EDR records behaviour, detects attacker techniques and provides investigation and response tools such as host isolation.
Do small businesses need XDR?
Most small businesses get more value from EDR plus an MDR service first. XDR becomes worthwhile as the number of security tools and alerts grows.
Related
Keep reading
SIEM vs SOAR vs XDR
Read more →Roll out EDR step by step
Read more →Incident response: the first hour
Read more →What Is a SOC (Security Operations Center)? Roles, Tools and AI SOC Explained
What is a SOC? How a security operations center works, SOC analyst tiers, core tools (SIEM, EDR/XDR, SOAR), in-house vs managed SOC, what an AI SOC is, and how it differs from SOC 2 compliance.
Read more →What Is a RADIUS Server? How RADIUS Authentication Works
What is a RADIUS server and how does RADIUS authentication work? The Access-Request flow, ports 1812/1813, common uses for Wi-Fi, 802.1X and VPN, popular RADIUS servers and how to secure them.
Read more →VPN Terms Explained: VPN Tunnel, Concentrator, Passthrough, Kill Switch and VPN Router
Clear answers to common VPN questions: what a VPN tunnel is, what a VPN concentrator does, VPN passthrough, VPN kill switch, VPN routers, split tunnelling and site-to-site vs remote-access VPN.
Read more →Need help designing your network?
Navijin engineers provide free design consultations, bills of materials and quotations for business projects.