Security · 9 min read
ZTNA vs VPN vs SASE: Which Remote Access Model Fits Your Business?
ZTNA vs VPN vs SASE compared: how each works, security and user experience, cost, and a practical migration path from remote-access VPN to zero trust network access for small and mid-size businesses.
A VPN connects a remote user to the whole network. ZTNA (zero trust network access) connects a verified user on a healthy device to only the specific applications they are allowed to use. SASE (secure access service edge) is a cloud architecture that delivers ZTNA together with SD-WAN, a secure web gateway, CASB and firewall-as-a-service. Most businesses move step by step: harden the VPN, add ZTNA for sensitive apps, and adopt SASE when branch networking and web security are refreshed.
Side-by-side comparison
| Remote-access VPN | ZTNA | SASE | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What the user reaches | A network segment, often broad | Named applications only | Applications, internet and SaaS through one cloud policy |
| Trust model | Trusted once connected | Verified per session and per app (identity + device posture) | Zero trust across users, branches and cloud |
| Lateral movement risk | High if credentials are stolen | Low: apps are invisible until authorised | Low |
| Exposed to the internet | VPN gateway listens publicly | Apps hidden behind brokers or connectors | Cloud points of presence |
| Main components | VPN gateway + client + RADIUS/MFA | Identity provider, policy broker, connectors, device agent | ZTNA + SWG + CASB + FWaaS + SD-WAN |
| Best for | Small teams, full-network admin access, site-to-site links | Remote staff and contractors reaching specific apps | Distributed organisations consolidating network and security |
Why VPNs became a target
Internet-facing VPN appliances have been among the most exploited devices in recent years, appearing repeatedly in CISA's Known Exploited Vulnerabilities catalog. A VPN that gives broad network access means one stolen password or unpatched gateway can expose everything behind it. That does not make VPNs obsolete, but it does mean they need MFA, fast patching and tight segmentation.
How ZTNA works
- The user signs in to the identity provider with MFA.
- An agent or browser check reports device posture: managed, patched, disk encrypted, endpoint protection running.
- The policy engine evaluates identity, device, location and time (attribute-based access control).
- The broker connects the user to the one application allowed, through an outbound-only connector, so the app never listens on the internet.
- The session is re-evaluated continuously and cut if posture changes.
This follows the zero trust principles in NIST SP 800-207: never trust by network location, verify explicitly, use least privilege and assume breach.
Where SASE fits
SASE, a term Gartner introduced in 2019, merges networking (SD-WAN) and security service edge (SSE: ZTNA, secure web gateway, CASB, firewall-as-a-service) into one cloud-delivered service. It suits organisations with many branches and heavy SaaS use. Smaller businesses often start with SSE, the security half, and keep their existing branch routers.
A practical migration path
- Harden the VPN today: MFA on every login, patch within days of advisories, and RADIUS hardened against Blast-RADIUS. Follow our remote-access VPN tutorial.
- Segment what VPN users can reach: per-group policies instead of full network access.
- Move sensitive web apps behind ZTNA with SSO and device posture. See zero trust step by step.
- Keep site-to-site VPN or SD-WAN for branch links, cameras and IoT, which cannot run ZTNA agents.
- Evaluate SASE at the next branch or firewall refresh.
Where Navijin fits
Navijin NavGATE gateways provide remote-access VPN, site-to-site VPN and NavCloud-brokered Auto-VPN between sites. Use them with segmentation and MFA as the network layer of a zero trust design. Ask our engineers to review your remote-access design.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between ZTNA and VPN?
A VPN places the user on the network, usually with broad access. ZTNA verifies the user and device for each application and connects them only to that application, hiding everything else.
Is SASE the same as ZTNA?
No. ZTNA is one component of SASE. SASE also includes SD-WAN, a secure web gateway, CASB and firewall-as-a-service delivered from the cloud.
Is VPN dead?
No. Site-to-site VPNs remain standard for branches, and remote-access VPN is still useful for administrators and small teams, provided it has MFA, fast patching and segmentation.
What is SSE?
Security service edge: the security half of SASE (ZTNA, secure web gateway, CASB, firewall-as-a-service) without the SD-WAN networking part.
Related
Keep reading
Zero trust step by step
Read more →Understanding zero trust architecture
Read more →Single sign-on for network management
Read more →What Is a SOC (Security Operations Center)? Roles, Tools and AI SOC Explained
What is a SOC? How a security operations center works, SOC analyst tiers, core tools (SIEM, EDR/XDR, SOAR), in-house vs managed SOC, what an AI SOC is, and how it differs from SOC 2 compliance.
Read more →What Is a RADIUS Server? How RADIUS Authentication Works
What is a RADIUS server and how does RADIUS authentication work? The Access-Request flow, ports 1812/1813, common uses for Wi-Fi, 802.1X and VPN, popular RADIUS servers and how to secure them.
Read more →VPN Terms Explained: VPN Tunnel, Concentrator, Passthrough, Kill Switch and VPN Router
Clear answers to common VPN questions: what a VPN tunnel is, what a VPN concentrator does, VPN passthrough, VPN kill switch, VPN routers, split tunnelling and site-to-site vs remote-access VPN.
Read more →Need help designing your network?
Navijin engineers provide free design consultations, bills of materials and quotations for business projects.